Today, I take the opportunity to thank the unsung heroes of our history: the brave and selfless Generals who have always forsaken their rights to martyrdom, choosing instead to suffer the misery of growing old with their children, and dispatched generations of men to everlasting glory.
On this day, how can I not thank the tactful Generals of ’65, the masterminds of the designed-to-fail Operation Gibraltar? The stalemate of a war you invited may have spilt innocent blood on both sides, and may have ended without the resolution of any issues, but it did put into reality for our nation that elusive philosophical concept, The Other: the perpetual enemy in whose opposition we must always define ourselves. We thank you for this important contribution to our national identity. We thank you also for being trendsetters, for your unprecedented actions have paved the way for the Generals of today.
I salute the resolve of the honourable Generals of ’71, whose tireless efforts made history. The mass murder that you oversaw in an assiduous, yet ultimately futile, attempt at maintaining our national honour and unity has rightfully catapulted Pakistan into a select list of proud nations alongside Japan and Germany. You tenaciously waged a war that most would have deemed unwinnable, just because it was honourable to do so. I have no doubt that the half a million Bihari patriots you deserted in Bangladesh join me in thanking you from their refugee camps for according us all this dignity.
I thank Allah daily for the benevolent Generals of ’77. An ambitious populist is a dictator-in-waiting, so thank you for pre-emptively liberating us by hanging Pakistan’s first popularly elected Prime Minister. It matters not if the charges against him were false: there is, after all, such a legal tradition as the Doctrine of Necessity. It is sad that only in the World Hereafter will we be able to properly thank you, O martyrs of Bahawalpur, for Islamisation and guns and drugs. It is no exaggeration to suggest that our thankless society will need a collective effort at a superhuman level to squander these gifts.
But the selfless Generals of ’07, I cannot thank enough. The entire Free World joins me in gratitude, my Lords, for you are beacons of freedom in the Muslim world. You have gallantly stood in the line of fire to defend us, and put Pakistan before all else. Your diplomatic acumen and political shrewdness have complemented each other to ensure that instead of being bombed ‘back to the Stone Age’, we will be suicide-bombed back merely a millennium and a half. To express our appreciation for this and so much more, the least we can do is to accept you and your successors as our Overlords for eternity; you are truly indispensable.
Dear Generals of the past and the present: thank you so very much. You have led us you with such exemplary tact, honour, benevolence and selflessness, that we continue to try and emulate you in our mundane civilian lives. You have shaped us as a nation, more so than any other force. You are the reason why any Pakistani, anywhere in the world, can proudly claim to be one. Were the great Noor Jehan alive today, she would surely re-dedicate to you her tribute to the fallen brave of September ’65:
Aey watan key sajeelay jawanu!
Meray Naghmey Tumharey Liay Hain…
O! Brave young men of the nation,
My songs are all for you…
------------------------
and for a tribute to the real heroes...
Aey watan key sajeelay jawano!
Meray naghmey tumharey liay hain.
Sarfroshi hai iman tumhara;
Juratoun keh paristar hau tum;
Jau hifazat karey sarhadoun kee,
Woh falak baus diwaar hau tum.
Aey shujaat key zinda nishano!
Meray naghmey tumharey liay hain.
Beweeion, maon, behnoun kee nazrein,
Tum kau dekhein tau yoon jagmagaein,
Jaisey khamoshion kee zubaan sey,
Dey rahee haun woh tum kau duwaein.
Quam key aey jaree paasbano!
Meray naghmey tumharey liay hain.
Tum peh jau kuch likha shairoun ney,
Uss mein shamil hai awaz meree;
Urh keh pohncho gey tum jis ufaq par,
Saath jaey gee perwaz meree.
Chaand taroun keh aey razdano!
Meray naghmey tumharey liay hain.
5 comments:
some one once said 'we do not fight the battles that we can win we fight the battles that are worth fighting for'.
samar who gives you the right to criticize any general. you start of with saying the operation of 65 was moronic. would you rather have indians killing hundreds of thousands kashmires. i would rather have a stalemate instead of a genocide[last count 80000 have died; isnt a single life worth saving as you so passionately point out our generals have no regard of]. no one remembers why pakistan supports freedom fighters all they remember is that it leads to war. then u start by cursing 71. yes i admit it lead to mass killings in bangladesh and no one disagrees to that but it was the SOB bhutto who refused to give the awami league the power that they had rightfully won and promised to 'break the legs' of anyone who went over to bangladesh to attend the confrences. his moronic finanacial schemes stopped all forms of foreign investments in pakistan and hundreds of companies who hired thousands of people left pakistan altogether. what he did later was too little too late.i would have had loved to see him hung a 100 times.
then again u come to the fiasco that turned out to be kargil. it wasnt just the generals that started the mission it was the politicians too. if you are one of those naive people who are willing to believe that nawaz sharif had no idea as to what was happening then i truely feel sorry for you.
then last but not least u claim that the present regime is doing wrong by claiming some control in the waziristan areas. those who think what happened in isloo was wrong ought to think about the women in isloo who had acid thrown on them just because they didnt wear the hijab. where in islam is anybody given such powers. these maulvis run away wearing burqas when the time comes to actually fight and tell 14 year olds to wear a bomb and boom.
these bombings are nothing but a desperate bid at retaliation by a select group whose main function is to spread nought but fear. no one in waziristan wants these mullahs or there own versions about islam in there lives and all they want is peace. musharraf should have had some back bone but some one should have told these people that being in pakistan means followings its laws a long time ago.
musharraf aint an prize but his economic growth stratigies are working. every single large economic organization like IMF etc agree that pakistan has seen remarkable improvement. it takes time for all the crap that the last 50+ years have created.
hopefully you will start seeing things in a different light.
ps since i aint a writer so sorry for all the mistakes
My Dear Anonymous Friend,
Thank you for your comments.
As for your question about my right to criticize Generals, it is mine by virtue of being a citizen of the Pakistani State. Last I checked, the Armed Services were meant to serve the country, and were, therefore, answerable to its citizens.
As for your comments on ’65, I see no evidence that Operation Gibraltar or the resulting war of September ’65 have in any way whatsoever helped the plight of the Kashmiri people, or eased their pain. If you have any such evidence, please share.
I disagree with you that Bhutto deserved to be hanged for his economic policy, because I do not believe anyone deserves to be hanged for his or her economic policy. Especially not by a military government on questionable charges completely unrelated to his or her economic policy. I am sure we can live in disagreement on that matter.
I did not mention Kargil even once in my piece, but since you bring it up, I agree: it was a fiasco initiated and masterminded by the Generals, with support from Nawaz Sharif’s government.
I am in agreement with you on Waziristan and Islamabad: the Army’s job is to enforce the writ of the State, and I personally support the actions against militant hideouts and Red Mosque. My problem however, with these operations today –or with ’65, ’71 or last year’s operations in Baluchistan –is this: if the brave men of our country are being sent to sacrifice their lives, it should be for a matter of utmost necessity, as determined by the people, not by a few whimsical Generals disconnected from reality.
As for Musharraf, I liked him when he came on, I really did. And there are things that he has done that he should be given credit for. But it is now time for him to go. The longer he stays, the weaker our democratic institutions get and the more we become susceptible to the influence of those who are your enemies and mine: those who encourage 14-year olds to strap bombs and die.
So, thank you for your comments. Please keep reading and commenting. We share the same purpose and love for Pakistan, and I am sure there is a lot we can learn by communicating.
All best,
Samar
dearest samar
one of the few things that i have come to hate about the pakistani culture is the ability of its people to criticize what little they have while not realizing a total lack of options. everybody takes great pride in cursing musharraf while not realizing that the alternates are far far worse.
i mean nawaz sharif is nothing short of a moron and a hypocrit. he been kicked out twice and still wants to come back[why doesnt anybody tell him to consider a career change]. i mean they guy claims he has no idea we had troops in kargil.what sort of a leader is that.
he had a problem with musharraf for starting the reference and yet he had no problem firing gen karamat to put musharraf[a junior level gen in place]. when musharraf starts to go out of control he decides to replace him and gets thrown out. he has a prob with the deals that musharraf makes but he was the one who escaped to saudi arabia when he knew that they wud prosecute him. i mean if he is such a great guy why didnt he stay and face the charges instead of turning his back on his countrymen. then he has says that musharraf is wrong for manipulating the constitution and he wants to amend it just so he can run again. come on
do i even need to tell anybody abt the $17 million corruption cases against benazir or american vow to attack us if MMA comes to power. i am of the view that in a country where religion is a part of culture or where economic divide exist a democracy can never exist. that country requires either a brilliant leader[like jinnah] or a tyrant[as in the case of iraq saddam hussein] to keep it together. while i am not supporting saddam i do realize that right now for pakistan its strongest institution is the only one that has the power to control it.
as for your answer about the 65 war i agree it may have even back fired because the paki soldiers in most cases[claimed by intl media] were given up by the kashmiri people BUT it is worth realizing that if that failed operation saved the life of a single person then it was not in vain. martin luther king once remarked that it was illegal in nazi germany to comfort a jew but had he been there he would have done so only because it was the right thing to do.
and i suspect we will always disagree on bhutto's sentence but had he never left his cushy foreign office job to join politics mujib ur rehman would have gained power[as he rightly should have] and maybe just maye pakistan wouldnt have been ripped in half.
once again i apologize in advance for any grammatical fauxpas
with regards
i dont think samar defended nawaz even once. corruption and diversity are always used by opponents of democracy as excuses for dictatorship. yet, generals are the most corrupt of them all, and least competent to deal with diversity of views given that they dont represent anyone except themselves. pakistani ppl deserve better than dictators.
and talking about options, why cant ppl be options themselves rather than blaming things on others?
i think this is a well written blog that highlights real problems of pakistan. how well the upper classes are doing in musharraf's new economy is no concern for most pakistanis
hey man, gotta be careful what you say. they gonna kill you if you're too cheeky
that said, i agree with everything you said. the only hope for pakistan is democracy. it'll suck in the short run, but in the long run, its the only option.
Post a Comment